kitchenaid ice cream maker

Best Ice Cream Makers Consumer Reports | Make Ice Cream Easily

Nothing can beat the feeling of having scoops of ice cream in the middle of a tiring summer day. And just like the old saying goes, if you want to do something right, you have to do it yourself. In this case, it means getting the right flavor and texture. The scoops that you are going to make yourself are going to taste less processed as well.

However, it would get quite difficult for you to carry out the preparation process without the best ice cream makers. Those will give you full control over the overall procedure, which will enable you to get the texture and flavor you were looking for.

Top Pics : 5 Best Ice Cream Makers

Top 10 Best Ice Cream Makers Reviews

Even though getting one of these devices might seem easy, in reality, you are going to find yourself in a tricky situation among all of the options that are out there. To make the choosing process easier for you, we have combined a list of the units that are recommendation worthy. Take a look:

1. Cuisinart ICE Cream Maker Review

Ice Cream Maker by Cuisinart, Ice Cream and Frozen Yogurt Machine, 2-Qt. Double-Insulated Freezer Bowl, Silver, ICE30BC

This Cuisinart ice cream maker has been one of the go-to options for many. Wondering why? Well, let us bring things down for you. It is also one of the best rated ice cream makers.

To start with, it is one of the fully automatic ice cream maker that they are offering. That means all you have to do is insert the ingredients inside it, and it will do the rest. The housing that it has is of stainless steel. As it is BPA free, you would not have to worry about it ruining the flavor as well.

Also, the motor on the device is heavy-duty. It also sports a large ingredient spout. That will make it easier for you to add flavors and other cooking ingredients inside it. And the bowl that it features is 2 quarts in size, which is enough for making multiple servings.

Finally, the bowl has double insulation. That will make sure that the temperature inside stays stable.

Highlighted Features

  • Fully automatic
  • Has a sizeable bowl
  • The body is BPA-free
  • Comes with a relatively large ingredient spout
  • The bowl has double insulation

Buy on Amazon

2. Nostalgia Ice Cream Maker Review

Old Fashioned Nostalgia Electric Ice Cream Maker with Easy-Carry Handle, Makes 4-Quarts of Ice Cream, Frozen Yogurt or Gelato in Minutes, Made from Real Wood, Brown

Are you on the lookout for something that has a relatively large-sized bowl? Then you should have a look at this 4 quart ice cream maker.

First of all, the unit features see-through lids. That will enable you to quickly monitor the ingredients and the freezing process. And the overall construction is pretty solid as well. It features the construction of high-quality wood. There is an easy-carry handle on the top, which will enable you to carry it easily.

Apart from that, the motor that it packs is quite powerful as well. It will do all the churning, which means you would not have to do anything manually. The package also includes plenty of delicious recipes, which will let you get started in your ice cream making adventure.

And the bowl is pretty easy to clean as well. Overall, this is one of the best home ice cream makers that you can get.

Highlighted Features

  • The bowl is four quarts in size
  • Features see-through lids
  • The construction is of sturdy wood
  • Has an easy-carry handle on the top
  • Packs a highly powerful motor

Buy on Amazon

3. Cuisinart Electronic Ice Cream Maker Review

Cusinart ICE-70P1 2-Quart Cool Creations Ice Cream, Frozen Yogurt, Gelato and Sorbet Maker, LCD Screen with Countdown Timer, Makes Frozen Treats in 20-Minutes or Less, Stainless Steel

Do you not have that amount of space in your kitchen worktop? Then you should definitely put this mini ice cream maker on your consideration list.

To begin with, it features a small and compact form factor. Because of how small it is, you would not have any trouble at all in accommodating it in your fridge and work station. Also, the bowl is 2 quarts in size, which is pretty large for making a medium batch of ice cream.

Aside from that, the paddler that it comes with is pretty advanced. It paddles relatively fast, which means it would be able to churn the milk quickly. Also, there is an LCD panel on the front, which will show you the current state and the inside’s temperature.

And there are three different modes that you will be able to set from. There are multiple speed options too.

Highlighted Features

  • Small and compact
  • Has a 2 quarts bowl
  • Comes with an improved paddler
  • Features an LCD screen on the front
  • Three different operational modes

Buy on Amazon

4. Cuisinart Ice Cream & Sorbet Maker Review

best ice cream maker

When it comes to offering the best electric ice cream maker, Cuisinart is one of the manufactures that goes all-in. And the same thing goes for this model that we will talk about.

To start with, it has a highly powerful and efficient motor. It is capable of churning the frozen treats in just 20 minutes, which means you would not have to wait long to enjoy homemade dessert anymore.

Apart from that, the ingredient spout on the side is pretty large in size. Also, it has an easy-lock lid that is quite easy to open and close. And, the overall size is pretty small and lightweight, which makes it a worthy pick for a portable ice cream maker.

Lastly, the bowl is ½ quarts in size, and it has double insulation. The container is also BPA-free, which means the flavor is going to stay all-natural.

Highlighted Features

  • Can churn frozen treats in just 20 minutes
  • Packs an efficient motor
  • Compact and highly portable
  • Features an easy-lock lid
  • The ingredient sprout is pretty large

5. Cuisinart Frozen Yogurt Ice Cream Maker Review

Cuisinart ICE-21P1 1.5-Quart Frozen Yogurt, Ice Cream and Sorbet Maker, Double Insulated Freezer Bowl elminates the need for Ice and Makes Frozen Treats in 20 Minutes or Less, White

You might be pretty tired of seeing a lot of Cuisinart units on our list. But because of how amazing and versatile these are, it is quite hard not to recommend them. This one, for example, is the best small ice cream maker that you can get.

First of all, you will not have to add extra ice to your recipe because of the double insulated freezer that it has. It also comes with an advanced paddler that will churn and make your frozen treats ready to eat in under 20 minutes.

The overall capacity of the bowl is also up to par. It is 1-1/2 quarts, which is more than enough for multiple servings. The transparent lid that it has on the top will enable you to monitor the overall process. And the large spout makes it easy to add ingredients while the unit is operating.

Lastly, the lid has an intuitive lock, which will make it effortless for you to open and close it.

Highlighted Features

  • Paddles frozen treats in under 20 minutes
  • Has a relatively large capacity
  • The freezer is double insulated
  • Features an easy-to-operate lock
  • The lid is transparent

Buy on Amazon

6. Hamilton Beach Ice Cream Maker Review

Hamilton Beach 68330N Automatic Ice Cream Maker, 4 Quart, White

Once professional ice cream maker units were pretty hard to come by. But thanks to manufacturers such as Hamilton Beach, that process has become quite manageable now.

First of all, the unit is exceptionally versatile. You would be able to make different versions of ice creams using the same machine. It includes a 20-recipe book in the package too. Also, there is an easy-to-open locking lid on the top.

Because of packing a powerful motor, there would be no need to manually paddle the milk either. Also, it stops automatically after completing the churning. Alongside that, the overall construction is of durable material too.

The overall capacity of the unit is reasonably large too. It can make up to 4 quarts batches in one go. Overall, this is an excellent pick if you were looking for the best home ice cream machine.

Highlighted Features

  • Exceptionally versatile
  • Includes a 20-recipe book
  • The lid is easy to use
  • Sports a powerful and efficient motor
  • Features a fully automatic operational mode

Buy on Amazon

7. Cuisinart ICE Compressor Ice Cream And Gelato Maker Review

Cuisinart ICE-100 1.5-Quart Ice Cream and Gelato Maker, Fully Automatic with a Commercial Quality Compressor and 2-Paddles, 10-Minute Keep Cool Feature, Black and Stainless Steel

If you were searching for the best compressor ice cream maker, then you can stop your search here because Cuisinart has got what you were looking for all this time.

To start with, it sports a commercial-grade compressor. It has a fully automatic operational mode, which means it would start and stop automatically once the food is ready. Also, the inside’s overall capacity is 1-1/2 quarts, which is more than enough to make multiple servings.

Alongside that, instead of utilizing one paddle, it implements a two paddle design. For that reason, the task of making ice creams would take you a short amount of time with this. Also, it has an LCD screen on the front, which will let you navigate through the different controls.

Lastly, the front has a touchpad control. It also has a timer mode, which will enable you to play with the textures a bit. The container is BPA-free as well.

Highlighted Features

  • Sports a commercial-grade compressor
  • The internal capacity is 1-1/2 quarts
  • Features an LCD screen on the front
  • The front has touchpad controls
  • Boasts a timer mode

Buy on Amazon

8. Nostalgia Electric Ice Cream Maker Review

Nostalgia PICM4BG Electric Maker with Easy-Carry Handle Makes 4-Quarts of Ice Cream, Frozen Yogurt or Gelato in Minutes – Blue

Having an easy cleaning procedure is a must for ice cream machines. And this one from Nostalgia has that.

Just like the label states, the overall capacity of the bowl is four quarts. That means you would be able to make a large quantity of ice cream in one go. Also, the upper portion has a see-thru lid, which will enable you to monitor the overall process. The top has an easy-carry handle as well.

Aside from that, the motor that it comes with is fully automatic. You will not have to do anything manually. Also, there is a motor locking mechanism. That will make sure that all of the parts are in place when you are moving the unit around.

And the cleaning procedure of the device is pretty straightforward. You would be able to clean the inside and the outside with just a simple wipe.

Highlighted Features

  • The internal bowl has a relatively large capacity
  • Easy to maneuver and carry
  • The cleaning process is straightforward
  • Sports a see-through lid on the top
  • The motor has a locking mechanism

Buy on Amazon

9. Cuisinart ICE Mix Serve Ice Cream Maker Review

Cuisinart ICE-45P1 Mix-it-in 1.5-Quart Soft Serve Ice Cream Maker, Make Professional Quality Ice Cream, Yogurt, Sorbet and Sherbet from Home, White

Not all of the people are really a fan of the hard and cold scoops. Well, if you are one of them, you are probably looking for the best home soft serve ice cream machine. In that case, you should check this unit out.

To start with, it has an easy-lock lid on the top. That will enable you to easily lock the lid when the machine is in operational mode. Also, the ingredient window will allow you to put ingredients directly on top of the servings.

Alongside that, the container is totally free from BPA. And the base contains a strong motor that will enable you to get soft servings within minutes. There is a conveniently placed dispensing bracket, which will enable you to get the right amount of serving in your bowl or cone.

Aside from that, the bottom has non-slip feet. All the parts are removable, which will make it easier for you to clean the machine.

Highlighted Features

  • The top has an easy-lock mechanism
  • Features a powerful motor at the base
  • The whole container is free from BPA
  • It comes with an ingredient window
  • The base has non-slip feet

Buy on Amazon

10. Cuisinart Ice Cream Maker With Touchpad Controls Review

best ice cream maker

Touchpad controls make operating ice cream machines a breeze. And Cuisinart had factored that in when they were manufacturing this unit.

Unlike some of the other units, this one comes with a touchpad control on the front. That will enable you to navigate through the different modes instantly. Also, the device sports a commercial-grade compressor that will make sure that the temperature inside is perfect through the entire preparation process.

Apart from that, the bowl has a good enough capacity to make multiple servings at one go. It also features a two paddle design that will accelerate the overall preparation process. There is a timer mode that will enable you to set your preferable time. The LCD panel on the upper side will display the countdown.

Lastly, Cuisinart has utilized high-quality materials for the overall construction. The materials are BPA-free as well.

Highlighted Features

  • Sports an easy-to-navigate touchpad controls on the front
  • Has an advanced timer mode
  • There is a large LCD panel on the top
  • Made of high-quality BPA-free materials
  • Packs two individual paddles

Buying Guide For The Best Ice Cream Makers

Going through the reviews only would not be enough if you want to get one of the well-performing devices. You would also have to keep some factors in mind. Now, you might be wondering what factors are we actually talking about here. Well, they are as stated:

best ice cream makers

  • The Bowl

First and foremost, you need to consider the size of the bowl. You should select the unit that has an appropriately sized bowl by factoring in how many servings or how large of a batch you want to prepare at one go. If you plan to make small batches, the ½ and 1-quarts one should be more than enough for you. However, if you plan to prepare in large quantities, you should opt for the larger ones.

  • Materials

Apart from the bowl’s size, you should also factor in the overall construction materials. If you happen to get a device that does not implement BPA-free materials, you would have a hard time trying to get a natural flavor in your ice creams. So, if you want to get scoops that do not have a weird taste to them, you should purchase the devices that utilize BPA-free materials.

  • Ingredient Spout

The ingredient spout is an important part of these devices. If you want to get complex flavors on your ice cream, you need to mix the ingredients during the preparation process. And the larger the spout, the easier it would be to mix ingredients while the machine is operating. Considering that, we would recommend shooting for the machines that have large-sized ingredient spout.

  • Paddles

best ice cream makers

Another part that you would have to consider while buying one of these machines is the paddles. Make sure that the paddles are large enough, or else it would take you hours to get a single scoop of ice cream. Also, if possible, get the units that come with two paddles. With those, you would be able to enjoy your frozen treats in just 20 minutes.

Also Read :

  1. Best Countertop Microwave Oven Review
  2. Best 4 Slice Toaster Consumer Review


Without getting one of the best ice cream makers, it would be quite difficult for you to churn and get a natural flavor. And hopefully, the narrowed-down list we have included in our article made it easier for you to choose one for yourself.

On that note, our best pick among all of the units that we have included would be Cuisinart ICE-30BCP1. It is one of the stainless steel ice cream maker that has a relatively large-sized bowl. Nevertheless, the rest of the devices will offer you decent performance as well.


Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published.