Cuisinart 7117-16UR Chef's Classic Stainless 16-Inch Rectangular Roasting Pan with Rack

Best Roasting Pan Cook’s illustrated

Whether you are planning your next holiday gathering or cooking for the neighborhood block party, the right roasting pan can bring delicious and wholesome feasts to everyone on your guest list, and best of all, save you time and energy.

That’s right! Roasting pans are wonderful cooking tools that are heavy-duty and durable enough to handle large volumes of foods that require cooking at high temperatures and for an extended time. These handy-dandy pans are a perfect addition to your cooking traditions all year long. From Thanksgiving turkeys to large slabs of ribs, roasting pans can handle it all. The best part is, most pans are made with nonstick materials, which make cleaning easy and painless.

In the following guide, we check out ten roasting pans to find that we think is the best roasting pan of 2018.

Product FAQ

1. What Is a Roasting Pan? 

Roasting pans are heavy-duty pans used for roasting foods.

2. What Does a Roasting Pan Do? 

Roasting pans are used to roast foods that require time to cook, such as turkey.

3. How Does a Roasting Pan Work?

You can use roasting pans for many purposes, including in the oven or on the stove top. Roasting pans feature heavy-duty materials that can withstand heat of up to 500 degrees. They are known to retain and distribute heat as the foods cook.

4. Where Can I Buy Them?

You can buy roasting pans at your local home retailer or online at Amazon.com.

How We Reviewed

The following products were reviewed based on the following parameter: Features, Pros & Cons, Price, Where to Buy, and Material. We looked at features to learn about the construction materials, whether there are any handles for transportation, temperature limit, and the durability of each pan. Looking at pros and cons, we were interested in how well each pan handled cooking and cleaning.

Overall Price Range of This Product (and Similar Products)

Roasting pans range in price from around $25 to $130. Some roasting pans cost more because they are made with higher-quality materials that can retain and distribute heat better. In addition, some roasting pans are bigger, come with a lid, and can be used as Dutch ovens, which can also explain the higher costs.

What We Reviewed

Cooks Standard 16-Inch by 13-Inch Stainless Steel Roaster

Image from Amazon

Roasting pans range in price from around $25 to $130. Some roasting pans cost more because they are made with higher-quality materials that can retain and distribute heat better. In addition, some roasting pans are bigger, come with a lid, and can be used as Dutch ovens, which can also explain the higher costs.

  • Viking 3-Ply Stainless Steel Roasting Pan with Nonstick Rack
  • Calphalon Classic Hard Anodized 16-Inch Roasting Pan with Nonstick Rack
  • Farberware Nonstick Bakeware 11-Inch x 15-Inch Roaster with Flat Rack
  • Gibson Home 64207.02 Top Roast 16-Inch Oval Roaster Pan with Lid and Rack
  • Granite Ware Covered Rectangular Roaster
  • All-Clad Stainless Steel Large 16 x 13 Inch Roaster with Rack
  • Cuisinart CI1136-24BG Chef’s Classic Enameled Cast Iron 14-Inch Roasting/Lasagna Pan

Viking 3-Ply Stainless Steel Roasting Pan with Nonstick Rack

Sale
Viking Culinary 3-Ply Stainless Steel Roasting Pan with Nonstick Rack, 16" x 13"
  • Includes 3-Ply Roasting Pan with Nonstick Rack
  • Unique inverted handles allow the roaster to fit into ovens with ease, minimizing space versus roasters with handles extended outward
  • Inverted handles make the roaster ergonomically easier to put into and take out of the oven
  • Roaster can fit up to a 25 point bird and comes with a v-shaped, PFOA and PFOE free Eternal Non-Stick cooking rack
  • Elevated rack helps cook food quicker and more evenly

Features 

The Viking 3-Ply Stainless Steel Roasting Pan is 8.5 quart in volume and comes with an induction lid, turkey lifter set, blaster, and a meat thermometer. This 3-in-1 pan works as either an open or covered roaster, and a Dutch oven. With a 3-ply construction, this pan is safe on all cooktops of up to 600°F. The interior of the oven is 18/8, which makes it easy to clean and secure the food’s flavors. This pan also comes with a wire rack to keep your food elevated while cooking. Finally, the signature Viking handles provide comfort and a secure grip.

Pros 

  • Quality construction
  • Easy to clean
  • Can be used as Dutch oven

Cons 

  • Rack is not as useful
  • Cooks unevenly for some  

Material

Stainless steel

Cuisinart 7117-16UR Chef’s Classic Stainless 16-Inch Rectangular Roaster with Rack

Features 

The Cuisinart 7117-16UR Chef’s Classic pan features professional stainless steel exterior and riveted stainless steel handles for easy and safe carrying. The stainless steel rack makes it easy to transfer your roaster in and out of the oven. In addition, the steel rack also provide heat circulation as meat cooks. Known as heat surround technology, this pan will cook up a feast. This pan also features stainless triple-ply construction, is induction-ready, and dishwasher safe.

Pros 

  • Easy to clean
  • Good size
  • Heavy duty
  • Nonstick
  • Induction ready

Cons 

  • Rack became warped
  • Takes a long time to cook
  • Doesn’t fit in some ovens

Material

Stainless steel

Calphalon Classic Hard Anodized 16-Inch Roasting Pan with Nonstick Rack

Sale
Calphalon Classic Hard-Anodized 16-Inch Roasting Pan with Nonstick Rack
  • Roasting pan made of medium-gauge hard-anodized aluminum for even heating
  • Nonstick interior ensures quick cleanup
  • Nonstick rack elevates foods for even browning, and allows fats and liquids to drain away
  • Highly polished stainless steel handles for safe, secure transport
  • Oven safe up to 450 degrees F

Features 

The Calphalon Classic Hard Anodized 16-Inch Roasting Pan features a durable hard-anodized surface that is both easy to clean and durable enough to be heated in an oven for up to 450 degrees. The hard-anodized aluminum material is top-of-the-line in heat conductivity. This pan is also nonstick, so cleaning is a painless process. The double-riveted stainless steel loop handles provide the safety and convenience all home cooks can appreciate.

Pros 

  • Easy to clean
  • Great for Thanksgiving turkey
  • Great size
  • Nonstick
  • lightweight

Cons 

  • Paint peeled off after brief use
  • Nonstick coating on the rack falls off after brief use
  • Pan warps after brief use

Material

Hard-anodized aluminum

KitchenAid KitchenAid KC1T16RP 16″ Tri-Ply Stainless Steel Roaster with Rack

KitchenAid KitchenAid 16" Tri-Ply Stainless Steel Roaster with Rack - Brushed Exterior and Polished Interior, Brushed Steel
  • We love dishwashers. In fact, we encourage you to wash this roaster in the dishwasher as often as you like.
  • Contoured stainless steel cast handles save space and ensure a secure comfortable grip, when placing, or taking large roasts, or turkeys in and out of the oven.
  • This sturdy, easy to clean removable rack is designed to rest at the ideal height within the roaster, keeping the food cooking out of oils and excess juices.
  • Our Tri-Ply Stainless Steel Roaster and Rack are ideal for heavy duty holiday use, or everyday use. Its excellence for cooking and heat retention can be used in ovens up to 500 degrees.
  • Nonstick U-shaped rack allows for even heat circulation around the entire roast, for crisp browning.

Features 

The KitchenAid KitchenAid KC1T16RP is made with nonstick material and features an elevated flat rack. This pan features heavy-gauge construction perfect for heat circulation. In addition, this pan can be heated up to 450 degrees in the oven, and the chrome-plated handles make it convenient to carry and store. This heavy-duty pan resists warping and provides an even browning to all foods during the cooking process.

Pros 

  • Easy to clean
  • Nonstick
  • Great size
  • Good quality, well made
  • Heavy duty

Cons 

  • Rust spots
  • Started flaking after short use

Material

Nonstick material, heavy-gauge construction

​Gibson Home 64207.02 Top Roast 16-Inch Oval Roaster Pan with Lid and Rack

Gibson Home Stainless Steel Top Roast 16-Inch Oval Roaster Pan with Lid and Rack
  • Includes 16-inch oval roasting pan, a lid and an interior rack
  • Non-stick interior for easy clean up
  • Crisp and clean stainless steel
  • Ideal for holiday dinners with ham, roast or turkey

Features 

The Gibson Home 64207.02 Top Roast Roaster Pan features a lid and an interior rack for keeping your foods suspended during the cooking process. This non-stick pan is 16 inches and oval, which makes it sizeable enough to fit large roasts. The nonstick material makes for easy and hassle-free clean ups, while the stainless steel material is durable and long-lasting. There are also handles on the side of the pan to provide convenient and secure grips for carrying. This pan is perfect for your next holiday party or family reunion.

Pros 

  • Easy to clean
  • Heavy duty
  • Perfect size
  • lightweight
  • Lid

Cons 

  • Too flimsy on the bottom for some users
  • Material too thin for some users

Material

Stainless steel

​Granite Ware Covered Rectangular Roaster

Sale
Granite Ware 25 lb. Capacity 19.5 in. Covered Rectangular Roaster, Speckled Black Enamel on Steel
1,546 Reviews
Granite Ware 25 lb. Capacity 19.5 in. Covered Rectangular Roaster, Speckled Black Enamel on Steel
  • Holds up to 25 lbs. Poultry.
  • Porcelain enamel surface is an inert, non-porous and naturally non-stick surface.
  • No PFOA, PTFE or other harmful chemicals & is Dishwasher safe
  • Safer than foil roasters, browns better and cooks more evenly. The dark porcelain surface absorbs the ovens energy and evenly distributes it so the contents are evenly cooked.
  • Granite Ware Roaster is Made in Mexico

Features 

The Granite Ware Covered Rectangle Roaster features a carbon steel construction and porcelain surface that provides for both top-notch heat distribution and easy clean-ups. This roasting pan also features a lid made with the same material for convenient storage. In addition, its durable material ensures even cooking and browning. When it comes time to clean the pan, stick it in the dishwasher as it is completely dishwasher safe. It can’t get any more convenient in regards to cleanup.

Pros 

  • Easy to clean
  • Granite ware
  • Great for turkeys
  • Lid

Cons 

  • Chipped easy
  • Small flakes
  • Inconvenient placement of handles

Material

Carbon steel and porcelain

​All-Clad Stainless Steel Large 16 x 13 Inch Roaster with Rack

All-Clad Stainless Steel E752C264 Dishwasher Safe Large 13 x 16-Inch Roaster with Nonstick Rack Cookware, 25-lbs, Silver
  • Roast meat, poultry, and vegetables to perfection with this versatile All-Clad E752C264 Gourmet Accessories large roaster. Holding up to a 20-lb. turkey, the heavy-duty stainless-steel roasting pan features tall, straight sides, which help prevent splatters and spills, while its upright handles ensure a secure hold when transporting the pan to and from the oven, even when wearing thick oven mitts. The roaster comes with a V-shaped nonstick roasting rack that elevates large cuts of meat to promot
  • Compatibility with all stovetops (except induction)

Features 

The All-Clad Stainless Steel Large Roaster is a heavy-duty roasting pan capable of cooking large roasts, including a 20-pound turkey. This pan is made with stainless steel materials, which make cleanup easy and hassle-free. With tall, straight sides on the inside the pan, you won’t have to worry about spills and splatters. Meanwhile, upright handles make carrying convenient and safe. This pan also features a V-shaped roasting rack that is nonstick and is the perfect tool for when you need to elevate your roasts from their juices. Finally, this pan is compatible with all stovetops except for induction stoves.

Pros 

  • Great for turkey
  • Nonstick
  • Easy to clean

Cons 

  • Could be pricey

Material

Stainless steel

​FeatCuisinart CI1136-24BG Chef’s Classic Enameled Cast Iron 14-Inch Roasting/Lasagna Pan

Cuisinart Cast Iron Roasting/Lasagna Pan, 14", Enameled Provencial Blue
  • Cast iron contraction retains heat well. The porcelain enameled interior is perfect for cooking, surfaces do not impact flavors or absorb odors.
  • Wide cast iron handles provide a comfortable and secure grip. Oven safe knob for a durable grip and endless cooking options.
  • Cast Iron construction provides superior heat retention and even heat distribution.
  • Strong, durable finish in rich colors complements any kitchen dcor. Perfect for cooking, serving and entertaining.
  • Convenient maintenance and easy cleanup and dishwasher safe

Features 

The Cuisinart CI1136-24BG Chef’s Classic Enameled Cast Iron Roasting Pan stands out among the other pans on this list for its cast iron material, which is great at retaining and distributing heat. On the inside of the pan, you’ll find porcelain enameled material, which is versatile and durable for all your roasting needs. In addition, there are wide cast iron handles to provide grip comfort and security. Choose from three colors: cast iron black, enameled provincial blue, and enameled cardinal red. Finally, this pan is dishwasher safe.

Pros 

  • Easy to clean
  • Can be used as Dutch oven
  • Perfect size
  • Holds the heat

Cons 

  • Chipped before using
  • Interior became splotchy after cleaning

Material

Cast iron, enameled porcelain interior

The Verdict

After reviewing all ten roasting pans based on the five parameters, we present our verdict for the best roasting pan of today: The KitchenAid KC1T16RP 16’’ Tri-Ply Stainless Steel Roaster.This pan provides the convenience you need and the quality you can count on. It’s made with triple-ply stainless steel materials perfect for roasting meats, vegetables, and everything in between. The contoured handles make transporting the pan to and from the oven convenient and safe. Don’t forget about the nonstick U-shaped rack. Not only is this rack great for ensuring heat circulation, but it also ensures an even and crisp browning during roasting. Finally, this pan is dishwasher-safe, so you can skip the hand-washing. If you are looking for a more budget-friendly option, consider the Cuisinart CI1136-24BG Chef’s Classic Enameled Cast Iron pan. While it is not the most inexpensive pan on this list, it is one of the best values with a great list of features and a price tag of around $50.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published.